All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by

The Lounge Board

AbsolutVT03

Joined: 01/05/2001 Posts: 30435
Likes: 16516


Your blanket statement of "Masks are largely ineffective" to start with.


Note that you didn't qualify that as "cloth" masks. Different masks provide different effectiveness based on a variety of factors. Lumping them all together as "largely ineffective" is flat out incorrect. But regardless of the level of effectiveness just about any mask is "worth it" because the effort/downside to wearing one is basically zero. Even assuming a cloth mask only provides a small benefit it's still going to be useful b/c it's such a minor "cost" to implement.

Then you try to say that wearing a mask "prolongs the pandemic" which doesn't even make sense especially given the statement preceding it. Then you trot out "Science tells us we will all catch the virus, better to do it now so we burn it out." which is not a good idea if you think about it. We have hospitals struggling with the surge created by omicron without everyone trying to catch it at the same time/as soon as possible. People have been using some form of that "we should all just get it and get it over with" since about the 4th month of the pandemic. It wasn't a good idea then... and it's still not.

"Science" doesn't tell us to do that at all. As we've seen even a less severe variant can still cause problems if it's massively contagious. You can still end up with as many or more people hospitalized or dead thanks to the sheer numbers involved. All it really needs is to be more contagious than it is less severe.

As far as insulting people who wear them, I'd argue that using the phrase "hide behind their almost worthless mask" is pretty insulting. Again it's similar to rhetoric we've heard since the early days of the pandemic. "Hiding in your basement". "Scared to live your life". Something tells me if I were to say you were only spouting such nonsense because you're "hiding behind" your keyboard you probably wouldn't take too kindly to that.

As far as calling you a "spewing ignoramus", I did no such thing. I said your post was ignorant and it is for the reasons I just laid out. I have no idea if you are an ignoramus or not. My post was specifically talking about your post and the views expressed within it. And honestly what would make me feel better is not seeing posts like that to start with. Like I said many of these arguments and fallacies are the same ones we've been seeing since 4-6 months into the pandemic.

(In response to this post by HokieJay)

Posted: 01/31/2022 at 9:55PM



+1

Insert a Link

Enter the title of the link here:


Enter the full web address of the link here -- include the "http://" part:


Current Thread:
  deepest prayers ** -- FfxStationHokie 01/31/2022 5:47PM
  You too. ** -- HokieJay 01/31/2022 5:50PM
  That is quite the oversimplification. -- HokieJay 01/31/2022 5:35PM
  OK Coach, good points, thank you. ** -- HokieJay 01/31/2022 7:27PM
  We absolutely need to stick together... -- HokieJay 01/31/2022 9:12PM
  I bet you'd wear one for Katie Adams... ** -- NokieHokie 01/31/2022 4:11PM
  Don't get all verklempt over it -- Victor Tango 01/31/2022 4:04PM
  You could drive. Bus. Train. Not travel -- Nova Hokie 95 01/31/2022 4:45PM
  Did somebody step on a duck? ** -- RoswellGAHokie 01/31/2022 4:07PM
  Go and take the mask off. You won’t be the only one. ** -- RoswellGAHokie 01/31/2022 3:46PM
  "Signs, signs, everywhere there's signs!" ** -- vthokieq 01/31/2022 4:00PM
  Good pull, great song! ** -- HokieJay 01/31/2022 4:39PM
  No smoking, no cussing, no fighting ** -- Brown Water 01/31/2022 3:57PM
  And no spitting! ** -- Brown Water 01/31/2022 3:59PM
  A little civil disobedience is a fine thing. ** -- RoswellGAHokie 01/31/2022 3:55PM
  A lot of it is finer. ** -- PhotoHokieNC 01/31/2022 4:00PM
  Im sure they are heart-broken ** -- capitals1 01/31/2022 3:32PM
  I agree with you ... -- vt90 01/31/2022 3:27PM
  Schools refer to them as the Virus Trapper Keeper. ** -- RoswellGAHokie 01/31/2022 4:01PM
  What CDC guidance are you referring to? -- Nova Hokie 95 01/31/2022 4:16PM
  They released several papers this month ... -- vt90 01/31/2022 4:21PM
  It seems the study contradicts your conclusion ... -- Nova Hokie 95 01/31/2022 4:27PM
  Makes too much sense ** -- FfxStationHokie 01/31/2022 4:39PM
  Help me out here ... -- Nova Hokie 95 01/31/2022 4:44PM
  We'll agree to disagree ... Go Hokies! ** -- vt90 01/31/2022 4:48PM
  Go Hokies! ** -- Nova Hokie 95 01/31/2022 4:49PM
  We're willing to risk you on that one ** -- Nova Hokie 95 01/31/2022 4:55PM
  A-men ... -- vt90 01/31/2022 4:00PM
  Dirty & judgemental stares? -- SteveInBaltimore 01/31/2022 6:17PM
  Must be more Karens near me 🤣 ** -- vt90 01/31/2022 7:05PM
  I've developed a good smirk for that ** -- Brown Water 01/31/2022 4:05PM
  I'm sorry this happened to you ** -- Gobbler-100 01/31/2022 3:24PM
  Well, there is always Penthouse Forum. ** -- Guy LeDouche 01/31/2022 3:14PM
  Maskless to be sure. ;-) ** -- HokieJay 01/31/2022 3:19PM
  You really showed them ** -- Brown Water 01/31/2022 3:13PM
  I wouldn't let that impact my life, but you do you -- jmanatVT 01/31/2022 3:08PM
  A profound oversight. I'll speak to them. ;-) ** -- HokieJay 01/31/2022 3:17PM

Tech Sideline is Presented By:

Our Sponsors

vm307