Critique of a technical defect of a player's style, mannerism, physical shortcoming, game day habit, etc. happen on the site. It could be misconstrued as a personal insult. Whether posters here 'feel' it is, or not an insult, doesn't matter much to the player or parent who might frequent the site. 'Sally has no range at SS' 'Suzie will never hit the riseball' 'Judy is too slow' These type of comments have happened. I think that is what the poster meant.