Why ruin a mayo sandwich? ** -- Guy LeDouche 02/21/2022 11:48AM
I find zero appealing about the idea -- Tafkam Hokie 02/21/2022 11:16AM
NFW ** -- MAHokie69 02/21/2022 07:22AM
Toast, buttered, peanut butter, 2 layers of banana slices! ** -- B777Fr8Dog 02/20/2022 11:36PM
Had them as a kid, but never as an adult ** -- EDGEMAN 02/20/2022 10:26PM
Like with peanut butter.** -- UsherDog2008 02/20/2022 10:21PM
Yes, banana and peanut butter is 👌🏼 ** -- MrBayAreaHokie 02/20/2022 10:33PM
Layer PButter , good to go ** -- astrohokie 02/20/2022 10:21PM
Catsup/ketchup sandwiches in a pinch ** -- TomTurkey 02/20/2022 9:56PM
Make it Duke's, and throw in some peanut butter ** -- Riverguy 02/20/2022 9:36PM
Wow...trifecta! ** -- HokieNerd 02/21/2022 4:43PM
I went thru a peanut butter, cheese and mustard sandwich phase as a kid ** -- Brown Water 02/20/2022 9:34PM
Add peanut butter and good -- Spudnut 02/20/2022 9:05PM
Pb jelly and banana. No mayo ** -- HokieJamie 02/20/2022 9:01PM
For me, has to be toasted bread. With jelly, too. ** -- TomTurkey 02/20/2022 9:27PM
Anything with Mayo, Hellman's, Miracle Whip, ETC. BIG NO>>>>>> ** -- UTPr0sim 02/20/2022 9:01PM
Nyet ** -- ColoVT82 02/20/2022 8:36PM
Ate them plenty growing up -- turkeywinghokie 02/20/2022 8:32PM
Yay! So my family is NOT totally insane...just looking for some redemption ** -- HokieNerd 02/20/2022 9:07PM
Like; and PB in place of mayo as well ** -- RTFC 02/20/2022 8:31PM
Curveball - did you or your family ever mix Kayo dark syrup with PB -- HokieNerd 02/20/2022 9:10PM
Nope not that one. Now dill pickle and PB sandwiches....that's a thing ** -- RTFC 02/20/2022 9:16PM
Sweet pickle, too ** -- TomTurkey 02/20/2022 9:28PM
My Dad used to make a few sammiches and cut them into quarter for a lunch. -- DonHo-kieHi 02/20/2022 9:37PM
I like all 3 of those things individually but the combo makes me think -- ME Hokie 07 02/20/2022 8:29PM
It was well before your time bud...but i get your sentiment! ** -- HokieNerd 02/20/2022 9:08PM
Ad peanut butter and you have the perfect sandwich ** -- capitals1 02/20/2022 8:24PM
Replace mayo with peanut butter and we’re good. ** -- vthokieq 02/20/2022 8:03PM
Yep, Elvis ...they are good...specifically asking about the Mayo -- HokieNerd 02/20/2022 8:11PM