Livorio vs Garnett is an old example of this. Livorio beat Garnett head to head but Garnett went on to become the starter because he matched up vs the field better than Livorio.

When you see someone in the room daily you know their tendencies and how to counter them so it’s not always the best way to decide on a starter. I’d say it’s only part of the evaluation. I wouldn’t set Catka and Borst as resolved yet.