5 oldtimers: Carroll Dale, George Preas, Frank Loria, Bob Schweicert, Don Strock

5 excitement players: MV1, Tyrod, Andre Davis, David Wilson, Corey Moore

5 blue collar guys: B Randall, Coale, Sam Rogers, Semones, Wayne Ward

5 you'd like to have back: Engleburger, Bruce Smith, Cornell Brown, Del Ricco, X

5 you can't forget: Shane Graham, D Lo, Macho, Suggs, Royal and I Ford (tie)

And even at 25, it's apparent that there are too many to narrow down to only 5.

Great idea by P_and_J