....informed consent all around. Let's further assume that those that fear infection can quarantine themselves to any degree they want - and avoid those lunatics who attend football games.

Why do you feel the need to protect those who are willing to take a risk? Have they asked you? NONE of my older friends want to lock down the economy - they are worried for the economy and opportunities for their children. They don't want the government (or you) trying to protect them. Just step out of their way and mind your own - as I have.