Its simple... the odds of a highly ranked player panning out are substantially higher than a player with 1 P5 offer. If you take many players that are highly ranked and add them to the roster, the odds of a higher percentage of those players turning into stars goes WAY WAY up. If you accept players with 1 P5 offer, you need every player to somehow turn into a 4* player and the odds of that are extremely low.

We saw that with Beamer's last classes, didn't we? And guess what, the last 2 years we have all complained that we are such a young team because the players with 1 P5 offer couldn't contribute despite being veterans. That will happen again if we take players with 1 P5 offer and a low 3* rating. Will you be surprised when it happens?