All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by

Conference Realignment Board

Joined: 04/10/2003 Posts: 8165
Likes: 518

5000+ Posts

Board Member 20+ Years

500 Likes

What's this?

In the rule, yes. In the process, no.

Discretion/flexibility in the rule allows the committee to consider non-champs.

In the process, if ND or any non-champ is "unequivocally" (undeniably, indisputably, etc.) in the top 4 then they are in. The committee has no discretion to exclude them.

Likewise, if they aren't, they are out. If there is any legitimate debate, e..g., your 4/5 scenario, then the committee does not have the discretion to select the non-champ.

(In response to this post by reestuart)

Posted: 07/29/2016 at 11:04AM

+0

PREV NEXT REPLY

Insert a Link

Enter the title of the link here:

Enter the full web address of the link here -- include the "http://" part:

Current Thread:

Tim Brando weighs in on ACCN and Big XII Expansion. -- HOO86 07/27/2016 9:49PM

What does UConn add fb wise? They certainly -- corvt2000 07/28/2016 2:43PM

UConn won the Big East in football in 2010. -- HOO86 07/28/2016 6:27PM

I Think UCONN would be on the ACC short list, they are not on mine ** -- BigCrumpy 07/29/2016 11:19AM

"Irish leaders will learn that opportunities are enhanced greatly by being -- Stech 07/28/2016 07:31AM

Until the theory is tested, we will never know. -- Maroon Baboon 07/28/2016 1:05PM

With ND playing a partial ACC schedule, there will be plenty of -- reestuart 07/28/2016 2:03PM

Agree, and they will wait a minimum of 10 years to find out ** -- VaTechie 07/28/2016 1:07PM

10 is a fair number, I'm thinking 2036 till we think about it again. :) ** -- goldendomer 07/28/2016 1:11PM

That's just an opinion and a stonger argument could be made to the contrary -- lawhokie 07/28/2016 12:27PM

An ACC schedule would not hurt recruiting or damage prestige. -- HOO86 07/28/2016 1:38PM

Being blunt but you formed an opinion before considering facts -- lawhokie 07/28/2016 10:22PM

If the ACC added Navy with ND, those games continue just like today. -- HOO86 07/28/2016 6:02PM

Notre Dame only grudgingly accepted 5 ACC games... -- lawhokie 07/29/2016 2:06PM

Conference Championship is a component of the selection, that's a fact and -- Stech 07/28/2016 12:45PM

Sure - but not nearly as much as beating good teams ** -- lawhokie 07/28/2016 5:29PM

Conference Championship is number 1 criteria. The ND Indy or die crowd has -- Stech 07/28/2016 7:27PM

Yep, but obviously we accept it ** -- goldendomer 07/28/2016 8:04PM

No doubt for you and TerryD and I am sure there are many others at ND, -- Stech 07/29/2016 07:24AM

I'm not one who worries about our place in the c.f. landscape if we joined -- goldendomer 07/29/2016 07:56AM

The selection committee already said -- BigCrumpy 07/28/2016 11:32AM

Jeff Long explains it over and over, but some choose to ignore him. -- HOO86 07/28/2016 1:40PM

When did they say that? They just took Oklahoma. ** -- reestuart 07/28/2016 11:40AM

Every time it is discussed. Look at the selection protocol for the CFP. -- HOO86 07/28/2016 1:46PM

They also say nobody is automatic... -- reestuart 07/28/2016 1:58PM

Jeff Long says it every time asked. Choose to ignore him if you wish. -- HOO86 07/28/2016 2:05PM

I'm not ignoring him. Here's a quote inside... -- reestuart 07/28/2016 2:12PM

Every time he is asked. He says the same thing. -- HOO86 07/28/2016 2:29PM

Like I said. A tie-breaker. They had no common opponents -- reestuart 07/28/2016 2:48PM

Oklahoma won the Big 12 Championship last year. ** -- Stech 07/28/2016 12:52PM

They also didn't play that 13th game he mentioned.** -- reestuart 07/28/2016 1:59PM

Yes and Michigan State jumped right over them when OU didn't lose. -- HOO86 07/28/2016 2:11PM

That could been due to geography as well. I guess we won't know -- reestuart 07/28/2016 2:17PM

It will be the natural instincts of the people sitting in the room. -- HOO86 07/28/2016 2:44PM

Very possible, but just as possible that they give the benefit of the doubt -- reestuart 07/28/2016 2:49PM

Not "just as possible" at all. this is the key language -- daveinop 07/29/2016 09:41AM

So they're saying they have the discretion to pick a non-champ or indy -- reestuart 07/29/2016 09:49AM

In the rule, yes. In the process, no. -- daveinop 07/29/2016 11:05AM

Well, I guess we won't know who's right until it happens. There is -- reestuart 07/29/2016 1:25PM

In the rule, yes. In the process, no. -- daveinop 07/29/2016 11:04AM

Re: When did they say that? They just took Oklahoma. -- reestuart 07/28/2016 11:54AM

I wouldn't hang my hat on this, he gave no real reason why -- goldendomer 07/28/2016 07:51AM

He gave no reason. It was just because. ** -- reestuart 07/28/2016 09:19AM

42% of your football schedule is in the ACC. The remainder is -- hokie4ever 07/28/2016 09:05AM

Yes, it matters -- TerryD 07/28/2016 10:56AM

They went from typically 3 to now 5 games vs ACC. That was a small -- hokeyhokie 07/28/2016 11:31AM

They are a partial football member -- BigCrumpy 07/28/2016 11:36AM

ND may have seen its last championship in any event -- TerryD 07/28/2016 12:37PM

I get that, and the last time ND played in one -- VaTechie 07/28/2016 1:15PM

42% to 66% is a huge jump when talking about 12 game schedules -- goldendomer 07/28/2016 09:50AM

Yep. It would basically rule out any OOC games for ND -- reestuart 07/28/2016 11:40AM

Not if they go to 4 divisions in the conference. They will get 5 OOC... -- Stech 07/28/2016 12:58PM

Do you mean that the ACC would go to a 7 game schedule? -- reestuart 07/28/2016 2:01PM

IMO 7 will be required to determine Div. champs. -- Red Hokie 07/28/2016 4:18PM

I like TB.He called ACCN in May.I do disagree with him that LHN saved B12. -- moonda 07/27/2016 10:09PM

Devils advocate: P16 happens and B12 dies -- Red Hokie 07/27/2016 10:40PM

It is a double story, it was the reason the PAC 16 blew up and it saved the -- Stech 07/28/2016 07:41AM

Well this will make Kelly more popular with fanatical base, not that -- goldendomer 07/27/2016 11:26PM