It was closer to being an indisputable catch than it was to being a non-catch. There was absolutely nothing in that replay to show that it was indisputably not a catch. Had it been called incomplete on the field, it would have been at least justifiable to keep the call on the field. Overturning the correct call was maddening. Though at the time of the game (in the third to last row in the Super Dome), I was more mad at the "fake" punt.