Your are essentially saying ratings aren't perfect. And for the upteenth time, no one says they are.

Forty percent of 5 stars make it to the NFL. We first discussed that here, oh, five years ago. Old news.

What you don't seem to grasp is, you have much greater chance of making it to the NFL as a 4-5 star than as a 2-3 star. THIS IS NOT UP FOR DEBATE.

So we need more 4-5 star players to be a better team.

And to pre-empt the next most common straw man: you also need great coaching and player development.