All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by

The Lounge Board

VTNuke

Joined: 01/18/2001 Posts: 7048
Likes: 4422


I kind of agree, except for one viewpoint


You can't just say people rebelled against the US and leave it at that. If you were from Georgia in 1860 and your entire state, including all of your friends and family, decided to leave the US and join the CSA, would you really consider being a member of the army of the CSA an act of rebellion? I don't think you would. You also probably wouldn't view slavery the way we do today, even if you didn't own slaves. You're viewpoint would be built by the experiences you've grown up with and wouldn't have the perspective that we have today.

History should never be judged by today's viewpoint. You should try to understand why a member of the CSA, even the Generals, would have felt the way they did about their home and their allegiances to protecting that home. We should also strive to understand the view of the slave to better comprehend the hardships they had living in that time.

History is in the eye of the beholder. How would you feel if in 30 years, your Grand kinds are asking why you were such a bad person for driving a car that polluted the environment? Would their viewpoint 30 years from now make you a bad person for doing what everyone is doing today? This is not to make excuses for those that take no action, but everyone's viewpoint is based on where they are in time and society.

Should people take down the statues? Sure, if that's what the City wants to do, that's the City's right to do it. If they don't, that's their decision as well. The citizens of the City should have the right to decide that even if it's only by supporting the elected officials that make those decisions by their votes or not. There really are way more important things to worry about than statues and monuments being taken down or not and I doubt either action will change the status of race relations anytime soon.




(In response to this post by MAHokie69)

Posted: 06/05/2020 at 3:33PM



+2

Insert a Link

Enter the title of the link here:


Enter the full web address of the link here -- include the "http://" part:


Current Thread:
 
  
Question about monument removal.... -- HokieGator 06/05/2020 12:22PM
  Hard to say but, really.... -- MAHokie69 06/05/2020 3:11PM
  We're not in Richmond anymore, Toto TIC ** -- TomTurkey 06/05/2020 3:16PM
  I agree -- VTSnake 06/05/2020 5:53PM
  Wow. ** -- reestuart 06/05/2020 3:00PM
  Talk about show and tell ** -- TomTurkey 06/05/2020 3:12PM
  Rick Steves says hey ** -- TomTurkey 06/05/2020 3:07PM
  No doubt. ** -- SavannaHokie 06/05/2020 2:17PM
  Depends on your history? are you a native ? ** -- Rodman6565 06/05/2020 3:31PM
  A native of what? ** -- vthokieq 06/05/2020 3:54PM
  Immigrants are natives? -- vthokieq 06/05/2020 4:03PM
  Yes I was and thanks for asking! :) ** -- Rodman6565 06/05/2020 4:05PM
  So you've been erased? -- vthokieq 06/05/2020 4:06PM
  I was an immigrant from 1720 best I can figure:) ** -- Rodman6565 06/05/2020 4:15PM
  Damn you're old! ** -- vthokieq 06/05/2020 4:15PM
  In most cases, it is -- bulab 06/05/2020 2:46PM
  But the statues "dignify" the "evil" to many. -- TomTurkey 06/05/2020 3:02PM
  /d No wonder the "edit" looked odd VVV** -- TomTurkey 06/05/2020 2:15PM
  "Let the name of Moses be stricken..." ** -- TomTurkey 06/05/2020 2:17PM
  People are strange...... -- Rodman6565 06/05/2020 1:22PM
  What exactly is being rewritten ** -- typed by ben 06/05/2020 1:55PM
  You tell me Ben? ** -- Rodman6565 06/05/2020 2:23PM
  I don't feel a need to reconcile it Hokie? ** -- Rodman6565 06/05/2020 2:24PM
  I think you know the answer to that ** -- Brown Water 06/05/2020 1:45PM
  I was giving the poster the benefit of the doubt ** -- HptHokie 06/05/2020 1:47PM
  ^^ This ** -- TomTurkey 06/05/2020 2:52PM
  Wasn't just blacks and Native Americans.... -- vthokieq 06/05/2020 2:25PM
  Nevermind. -- vthokieq 06/05/2020 2:35PM
  Exactly , to 1860 standards to be precise -- Vippie1 06/05/2020 1:36PM
  I ahem am hoping to get Erected this weekend. ** -- GreenvilleVT 06/05/2020 1:33PM
  Sincere best wishes to you ** -- typed by ben 06/05/2020 1:45PM
  Thank you for your take, Rush Limbaugh. Sheesh ** -- 81_Hokie 06/05/2020 1:11PM
  Lame response 81! ** -- Rodman6565 06/05/2020 1:15PM
  Prince William County Schools jump into the fray -- Hokie1992 06/05/2020 1:05PM
  Good one, not ** -- Vippie1 06/05/2020 1:15PM
  You are offering reason. Folks who are willing to loot -- GreenvilleVT 06/05/2020 12:31PM
  Hard to understand when its not you being abused.** -- UTPr0sim 06/05/2020 12:55PM
  How do you know what abuse I have taken? -- GreenvilleVT 06/05/2020 1:13PM
  Got it. ** -- GreenvilleVT 06/05/2020 1:44PM
  Put them in a museum -- HptHokie 06/05/2020 12:28PM
  I agree with what you are saying in principle -- VTHokie2000 06/05/2020 1:25PM
  They are being put in storage. -- vtbones 06/05/2020 1:12PM
  Here: -- HokieGator 06/05/2020 1:17PM
  Nowhere, I think folks are presuming that ** -- `lag 06/05/2020 1:15PM
  Yeah, I agree. it happened...right...here. ** -- `lag 06/05/2020 12:59PM
  Totally agree -- turkeywinghokie 06/05/2020 12:52PM
  Funny thing if I recall correctly -- Vippie1 06/05/2020 1:14PM
  Well, we're talking about America here -- Chris Coleman  06/05/2020 1:04PM
  The winners get to write history. ** -- Stork 06/05/2020 2:32PM
  Well said! ** -- hokieblitz 06/05/2020 2:21PM
  I read your first sentence in Ron Burgundy's voice. -- s.mill hokie 06/05/2020 1:28PM
  Does it really matter what we teach? -- GreenvilleVT 06/05/2020 1:18PM
  No doubt. -- Chris Coleman  06/05/2020 1:20PM
  Oh...nice quote! ** -- vthokieq 06/05/2020 1:21PM
  Yep. It's always been one of my favorites. -- Chris Coleman  06/05/2020 1:22PM
  I could apply it to years. ;-) ** -- vthokieq 06/05/2020 1:23PM
  Agreed. ** -- Chris Coleman  06/05/2020 1:26PM
  I haven't, but it wouldn't surprise me. ** -- Chris Coleman  06/05/2020 1:19PM
  Quick youtube video inside... -- NokieHokie 06/05/2020 1:32PM
  +1 for your first paragraph. ** -- AZHokie59 06/05/2020 12:59PM

Tech Sideline is Presented By:

Our Sponsors

vm307